The Transformation of Time and Space

Introduction

In his seminal article, Einstein elegantly derived the Lorentz transformation for time and space between systems moving at constant relative velocity. His original derivation assumed that the relative velocity was aligned with the x-axis, and implicitly considered the measurement of length perpendicular to this velocity direction to be consistent in both systems. In this section, we will follow Einstein reasoning and extend the derivation to a more general case—a boost in any arbitrary direction. Our goals are as follows:
  1. General Boost Transformation:
    • We will derive the Lorentz transformation for a general boost, where the relative velocity is represented by an arbitrary vector.
    • This broader approach allows us to handle boosts in any direction, not just along the x-axis.
  2. Preserving Length Perpendicular to Velocity:
    • We will explicitly discuss the conditions that ensure the preservation of lengths perpendicular to the velocity direction.
    • This consideration is crucial for maintaining consistency across reference frames.
  3. Time Transformation via Clock Synchronization:
    • Following Einstein original method, we will derive the transformation of time based on clock synchronization.
    • This step lays the foundation for our subsequent analysis.
  4. Lorentz Transformation for Time and Space:
    • Leveraging the invariance of the speed of light, we will derive a concise expression for both time and space transformations.
Assumptions and Prerequisites: We assume that readers are familiar with advanced calculus, linear algebra, and the fundamental principles of Special Relativity. We will make use of the bra-ket notation, which readers can get familiar with here.

Synchronization of Clocks

In Special Relativity, the concept of clock synchronization assumes a pivotal role in developing the Lorentz transformation of time and space. Although seemingly straightforward, we will delve into a detailed explanation of this fundamental concept, as defining synchronization becomes essential for determining when events occur simultaneously. Let us delve into the starting point of our exploration. Imagine two observers, A and B, both at rest within the same reference system but positioned at different locations. These observers, A and B, each have their own clocks, measuring time independently. Now, let us imagine an experiment where a photon is emitted from A, travels to B, and gets reflected back to its origin in A. Observer A records the time of emission as , while observer B notes the time of reflection as . Finally, A marks the time of the photon arrival as . We assume that both A and B have access to each other time recordings (for example they would exchange data after the experiment). A possible outcome of this experiment could be as per the table below (units of time are not relevant in this discussion):
Time in A Time in B Event
1 2 Emission,
3 4 Reflection,
5 6 Arrival,
If the observer at point B used the time difference to compute the time needed for the photon to reach B, they would obtain an incorrect result of 3 instead of the actual value of 2. More worrisome, the time difference would be 1, indicating a relative motion of the two observer which are at rest in the same reference system. These discrepancies occurs because the two clocks are not synchronized. The way for B to synchronize their clock with A is to record the time stamp , wait for the photon to get back to A, ask A for , and set the clock in B such that:
which is realized in this case by setting their clock back 1 unit. The synchronization of clocks is essential for determining how time and space are measured when we consider events observed by two systems of reference now in motion with respect to each other. This is the subject of the next sections.

Transformation of Time

In this section we will derive the equation for the transformation of time between two systems of reference moving at constant relative velocity.
The mirror Experiment
Let us explore the mirror experiment from the perspective of a new reference frame. In this scenario, the mirror and the emitting source are both at rest within a system of reference , which itself is in motion relative to another system of reference . Observers in measure time and distance as and , while observers in measure time and distance as and . We assume that at time zero the origin of the systems coincide.
Fig 1:Photon Emission and Reflection in
The source is located at the origin of and the mirror is positioned at a fixed distance along an arbitrary direction. A photon is emitted at a time , it reaches the mirror at time where it is reflected, and it arrives back at the source at time . As we assume that the clocks in are synchronized, the following relation holds true:
Clock Synchronization
Now we examine the three events—emission, reflection, and arrival back at the source—from the viewpoint of reference frame . It is crucial to emphasize that all time, velocity, and distance quantities in this section are assumed to be measured within the system of reference . The photon is emitted from the source at time and at the position where is the velocity of measured from .
The photon travels to the mirror with speed , and it reaches it at a time:
where is the distance of the mirror from the source measured from , and is the photon velocity in as observed in . When the photon reaches the mirror its position will be
Fig 2:Velocities and positions of the photon seen from
The time when the photon reaches the source back again is
where is the photon velocity returning to the source. The position of the photon when it meets the source is,
To derive the Lorentz transformation, we will assume the existence of a functional relationship between and ,
and formally, the events of emission, reflection and meeting the source again will be observed in as
expanding the function ,
in Taylor series around zero we obtain,
A similar expression holds true for ,
Using the synchronization condition of Loading..., we arrive at the differential equation in (for ),
where,
Assuming a linear relationship between the time in and the coordinates in as,
where is a vector transforming the spatial coordinates and is the coefficient transforming time, we arrive at the linear equation in and
Condition On P
The Loading... can be further simplified if we look in detail to the direction of the vectors , and . Since the photon in follows the same direction going to the mirror and back to the source, and are parallel, but have different magnitude; hence , and are all in the same plane, see Fig (3).
In the system of reference of three mutually orthogonal unit vectors , , and , with and in the same plane of and , and in the same direction of , the vector has components,
and equation Loading... simplifies to
Fig 3:The photon velocities
as can be set to zero as it is orthogonal to the plane of and . From
we arrive at
which has solutions
The transformation of time between and becomes then
Transformation Of Time
where is a constant depending on the velocity.

Transformation of Space

General Form of the Lorentz Transformation
The Lorentz transformation describes how the coordinates and the time of the same event observed in and are related to each other, and it is assumed to be linear
where is a matrix depending only on the velocity vector , and is the so-called four-vector
A four-vector can be represented as sum of ket vectors formed from a unitary triplet of orthogonal vectors , and , with chosen parallel to
and the Lorentz transformation in its most general form becomes
General Form Of Lorentz Transformation
where are sixteen free parameters. The Loading... can be utilized to identify some of the but not all of them: assumptions need to be made on how events are observed in and to restrict the possible choices for .
The transformation of time
The transformation applied to a four-vector with only a time component: gives,
but from the Loading... there are only components along and time, hence .
First assumption: preserve direction along
The first assumption we make is that the direction is invariant, meaning that an event in with components only along will not have components along the other directions in . Given an event , its transformation in will be,
this results in to satisfy our assumption. The Loading... further simplifies as,
Second assumption: invariance orthogonal to
The second assumption needed is that the spatial components along and of any event preserve their direction and length under . For an event , the corresponding event in will be,
Our assumptions is satisfied if and , which results in a further simplification of :
Using the Loading..., we arrive at the final functional form of
Simplified Lorentz Transformation
Finally, the constants and must be positive to prevent axis reflection.
Third assumption: invariance of light speed
In Special Relativity the spacetime interval between two events and is defined as
and can be written in bi-linear form as
where and
A spacetime interval measured in is linked to the same interval in by the Lorentz transformation
In the system we consider a photon moving along an unitary vector . The photon at time is in the position , and moves to the position at the time . The spacetime interval in of the two events is identically zero,
When we examine two events occurring along the trajectory of a photon (referred to as the photon’s world line), the spacetime interval, the spacetime interval in must also be zero, assuming that the speed of light remains invariant,
equivalent to,
Invariance Of Speed Of Light
for all such that . To solve the equation above we need , which is with the time component changed sign,
and is readily obtained by exchanging the bra and ket vectors,
The product is
and the equation for the Loading... reads,
Choosing or and ,
Choosing and ,
and we arrive at the system of equations
which has the following admissible solutions,
The Lorentz transformation takes the final form
Lorentz Transformation
The inverse of transforms the coordinates from to and can be readily obtained by exchanging the velocity sign, as it can be verified directly
Inverse Of Lorentz Transformation
The Lorentz transformation written explicitly in terms of the velocity vector, as , reads,
Lorentz Transformation In Velocity
When has the direction of the x-axis, the transformation simplifies to the original Einstein formula
One Dimensional Lorentz Transformation
Finally, it can readily proven that the Lorentz transformation satisfies the condition , hence for all events, not only those on a world line of a photon,
Invariance Of Spacetime Interval